Top Sales Closed in January: 3 Vintage Chicago Luxury Masterpieces, 2 Luxury New Construction

Looking at the luxury Chicago homes that sold and closed, the month of January was highly unusual. The top five sales were each extremely unique, including two brand-new construction properties along with three vintage architectural masterpieces which sold for major, major discounts. The three vintage homes are truly special properties—but for real estate like this, there is often a limited pool of buyers, and would require a real investment in artistry to bring these gems back to their original grandeur.

All in all, January saw $77 million in total sales volume of Chicago luxury homes, with nine of those homes selling for more than $2 million. There’s lots to cover, so let’s jump right in to the top five single-family homes that sold in January, starting with the most expensive:

2466 N Lakeview Ave2466 N Lakeview Ave
Original list price: $7.15 million
Sold price: $4.65 million
This is Chicago’s historic “Wrigley Mansion,” a magnificent estate that was designed by famed architect Richard Schmidt and built in 1896. It spans more than 13,000 square feet, across a main house and additional structures on the property. The main house features 9 bedrooms, 6.3 baths, a grand foyer, a solarium, butler’s pantry, wine bar, walk-in vault, game rooms, staff quarters, a mahogany paneled library, sprawling master suite and a top-floor ball room with unobstructed views of Lincoln Park and Lake Michigan. It also includes a 2,000 square foot coach house with ground-floor storage and garage bays with two residential units above. Special details include mahogany cherry and bird’s eye maple woods throughout, marble fireplaces and fixtures, intricate mosaic tile, ornate hardware, gold and silver leaf finishes and coffered ceilings.

You’ll notice this home sold for more than $2.5 million less than the asking price—that’s quite a significant discount. This home was sold as a foreclosure, and while it holds a ton of history, was in need of some significant rehab, which likely helped the cash buyer do some major negotiating on the list price.

1440 N Dearborn Pkwy1440 N Dearborn Pkwy
Original list price: $6.45 million
Sold price: $4.625 million
This vintage property also sold for a major discount—nearly $2 million under asking price. The buyer paid cash, which likely gave him or her a leg up in negotiating the final price. The home is in the Gold Coast’s historic district near Oak Street Beach and the Magnificent Mile. Its style is a total stand-out, a gilded age mansion designed by James Egan with a blend of fresh Romanesque style architecture modernized for today’s buyer. The vintage charm lends itself to exceptional details, such as an elegant Tiffany stained glass oval skylight on the top level. But the rest of the home has been completely renovated across its four levels, five bedrooms and 5.2 baths, with a spacious open floor plan made for entertaining, a top-of-the-line gourmet kitchen with butler’s pantry, dining room and formal living room, plus a finished lower level with guest suite, exercise room and two wine cellars. Outside, the 150-foot-deep lot allows for plenty of space for a private, landscaped backyard paved with limestone.

1831 N Fremont St1831 N Fremont St
Original list price: $3.495 million
Sold price: $3.495 million
This is a brand-new brick and limestone home on the tree-lined Fremont Street in Lincoln Park. This new home offers more than 5,200 square feet of luxurious living space that is bright and airy, thanks to oversized windows throughout. Design details inside include custom cabinetry and millwork, professionally designed natural stone baths, a luxe master bath with oversized steam shower, separate vanities and private water closet. Outside, you’ll find a tremendous outdoor space including a yard, rear patio, garage deck and secluded rooftop deck with covered patio and fireplace. Plus, the home includes a radiant-heated lower level, front steps and rear walkway along with an oversized two-car brick garage.

1248 N Astor St1248 N Astor St
Original list price: $3.65 million
Sold price: $3.15 million
Built in 1886 on a 29-foot lot, this architectural gem in the Gold Coast is located on one of the city’s most prestigious blocks. The three-story limestone home spans 8,000 square feet with six bedrooms and 6.1 baths. Period details brings a certain stately dignity to this home, such as a wide foyer with custom millwork, a restored original staircase, a beautifully restored fireplace and a wood-paneled library overlooking Goudy Park. The floorplan offers generous room sizes, a grand living room and dining room off the kitchen, plus high ceilings and hardwood floors throughout. You’ll even find the most coveted feature of any Chicago property: spectacular lake and city views.

This home also sold for well below the asking price—a whopping half million dollars.

2022 W Moffat St2022 W Moffat St
Original list price: $2.395 million
Sold price: $2.33 million
The final top sale from January was another brand-new build, this one made to be a 4,800 square foot contemporary dream home. The home was built on a hard-to-find 36-foot lot, which allows for an incredible floor plan with huge windows in the living and dining area that bring in southern light all day. A massive, open-concept living and kitchen area opens directly to a 30-foot long terrace and enormous roofdeck for the best in indoor-outdoor living. Upstairs, the second floor boasts four bedrooms and three baths, plus laundry; the master suite includes a sumptuous spa-like bath and massive walk-in closet, and on the lower level you’ll find a rec area complete with wet bar. Features aside, the location of this home can’t be beat, as it’s right off of Damen in Bucktown and within walking distance to parks, restaurants and shopping.

The top sales for January saw a mix of vintage stunners and contemporary new builds. This is one of my favorite things about Chicago real estate—if you’re a luxury buyer, you can find something that fits your taste, whether that’s old-world charm or new-age modern or something in between.

To learn more about the top sales closed in Chicago last month, or to see what’s on the market now, contact me at (312) 498-5080 or email me at

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *